Private Area

For Shelby and Kachina

Woooo

This vote is insane.

We needed this room PM are a pain

Yes it is.

Dnash finally messaged me to tell me who he voted

dnash wrote:But to answer your question, I do think I'm seen as a vote that's in the middle. I've gotten to know people on both sides, but I know that one side has talked to me a lot more post merge than the other, so that's how I'm basing my decision tonight.

Wow so we do not talk to him enough

I talk to him a lot though. Did he say he was voting for Aaron? I'm so confused.

He suggested Ryan, then told me he was voting for Aaron.

He told me in a PM he voted Aaron

dnash wrote:Hi I'm good, I voted Aaron

I trust that he did.  My only concern is that they're just using him to deflect his vote, making it 4 vs. 4.  Then if Dayman can sway one of us, they automatically have the majority without needing Dnash's vote and leaving him out of the vote, and they can freely blindside anyone.

However, if they really did all vote Aaron, it's an easy way to waste idols and sever any possible working relationship with Dayman if he's telling the truth.  

The first scenario seems unlikely as it would take a lot of thought and planning.  But after talking to Dayman, who clearly puts in a lot of thought and planning, it's possible.

Whatever we do, it's the right decision if we get it right and the wrong decision if we get it wrong.  We won't know until the results are posted, though.

Sorry im here almost forgot

What should we do

I still don't know.

Aaron is likely going regardless, unless one of us plays an idol for him, and unless they're tricking us. But most likely Aaron is going. So it really doesn't matter who we vote for. Voting Ryan will make Shy Guy happy but it will also give Ryan an advantage, voting Aaron will probably give us both another idol clue (unless someone was sneaky in those first tribals) and at least temporarily put us on better terms with Dayman - if we vote with them, they have reason to vote with us the next 2 votes before backstabbing us will give them an advantage.

Those are the pros and cons. What do you think?

I wish we knew who Aaron was voting because we may have had the upper hand if he would have talked to us.

Maybe they are lying and voting someone else. If so and we go against shy guy we have no one

I guess we have no choice but to vote Aaron, I dont want to do it but it might make Dayman happy unless he is just pulling us a long to save him self.

I could use my idol to save him but he has not bothered to talk to any of us

I wish we would have voted Dnash out and kept ID

Yeah. If you use the idol at all use it to save yourself just in case they're bluffing with the vote. No sense in wasting it on Aaron.

We'll find out soon.

Im not using it I voted Aaron

If shyguy gets mad oh well, he has not talked to me since the merge either until just now

I told him Dnash flipped back to them and voted Aaron, which is true. And that if we all vote Ryan, we'll give Ryan an advantage. He had already voted Ryan, but voting Aaron keeps Ryan from getting an advantage. Assuming this is all as it seems. Should have results in half an hour or so. I'll be back later.

Got the clue! I'm guessing you did, too.

If you're going for it tonight, let me know so I don't, too. We potentially have 2 more idols, no sense in competing with each other.

Okay I will go ahead and try for it tonight

Good luck!

milli wrote:Hi Shelby! It's nice to talk to you personally finally. I think a lot of us were expecting the vote to be closer last night, and we were not expecting 7 votes against Aaron. What do you think caused the shift?

Just got this PM from Milli

I got a similar PM from Milli. I just told her that Aaron never talked with me about the vote, so I just went with what I heard from others.

Shes fishing for info. How sneaky

She is. Not very well, either.

Got it

Awesome! Congrats! I'll go for it next time, and hopefully we can get 4 idols between us.

Sounds good. Dayman sent me a message saying sorry he took a point from me and that he still wants to work with me.

I asked him if he had anyone he wanted out and he said I think we will do what dnash wants since he has all the power. Not sure what he meant by that.